RFC1493

From RFC-Wiki

Network Working Group E. Decker Request for Comments: 1493 cisco Systems, Inc. Obsoletes: 1286 P. Langille

                                       Digital Equipment Corporation
                                                      A. Rijsinghani
                                       Digital Equipment Corporation
                                                       K. McCloghrie
                                            Hughes LAN Systems, Inc.
                                                           July 1993
                 Definitions of Managed Objects
                          for Bridges

Status of this Memo

This RFC specifies an IAB standards track protocol for the Internet community, and requests discussion and suggestions for improvements. Please refer to the current edition of the "IAB Official Protocol Standards" for the standardization state and status of this protocol. Distribution of this memo is unlimited.

Abstract

This memo defines a portion of the Management Information Base (MIB) for use with network management protocols in TCP/IP based internets. In particular it defines objects for managing MAC bridges based on the IEEE 802.1D-1990 standard between Local Area Network (LAN) segments. Provisions are made for support of transparent bridging. Provisions are also made so that these objects apply to bridges connected by subnetworks other than LAN segments.

The Network Management Framework

The Internet-standard Network Management Framework consists of three components. They are:

  STD16/RFC 1155 which defines the SMI, the mechanisms used for
  describing and naming objects for the purpose of management.
  STD16/RFC 1212 defines a more concise description mechanism, which
  is wholly consistent with the SMI.
  RFC 1156 which defines MIB-I, the core set of managed objects for
  the Internet suite of protocols.  STD17/RFC 1213, defines MIB-II,
  an evolution of MIB-I based on implementation experience and new
  operational requirements.
  STD15/RFC 1157 which defines the SNMP, the protocol used for
  network access to managed objects.

The Framework permits new objects to be defined for the purpose of experimentation and evaluation.

Objects

Managed objects are accessed via a virtual information store, termed the Management Information Base or MIB. Objects in the MIB are defined using the subset of Abstract Syntax Notation One (ASN.1) [7] defined in the SMI. In particular, each object is named by an OBJECT IDENTIFIER, an administratively assigned name, which specifies an object type. The object type together with an object instance serves to uniquely identify a specific instantiation of the object. For human convenience, we often use a textual string, termed the descriptor, to also refer to the object type.

Format of Definitions

Section 5 contains the specification of all object types contained in this MIB module. The object types are defined using the conventions defined in the SMI, as amended by the extensions specified in [9,10].

Overview

A common device present in many networks is the Bridge. This device is used to connect Local Area Network segments below the network layer.

There are two major modes defined for this bridging; transparent and source route. The transparent method of bridging is defined in the draft IEEE 802.1d specification [11]. This memo defines those objects needed for the management of a bridging entity operating in the transparent mode, as well as some objects applicable to all types of bridges.

To be consistent with IAB directives and good engineering practice, an explicit attempt was made to keep this MIB as simple as possible. This was accomplished by applying the following criteria to objects proposed for inclusion:

      (1)  Start with a small set of essential objects and add only
           as further objects are needed.
      (2)  Require objects be essential for either fault or
           configuration management.
      (3)  Consider evidence of current use and/or utility.
      (4)  Limit the total of objects.
      (5)  Exclude objects which are simply derivable from others in
           this or other MIBs.
      (6)  Avoid causing critical sections to be heavily
           instrumented.  The guideline that was followed is one
           counter per critical section per layer.

Structure of MIB

Objects in this MIB are arranged into groups. Each group is organized as a set of related objects. The overall structure and assignment of objects to their groups is shown below. Where appropriate the corresponding IEEE 802.1d [11] management object name is also included.

      Bridge MIB Name                  IEEE 802.1d Name
      dot1dBridge
        dot1dBase
          BridgeAddress                Bridge.BridgeAddress
          NumPorts                     Bridge.NumberOfPorts
          Type
          PortTable
            Port                       BridgePort.PortNumber
            IfIndex
            Circuit
            DelayExceededDiscards        .DiscardTransitDelay
            MtuExceededDiscards          .DiscardOnError
        dot1dStp
          ProtocolSpecification
          Priority                     SpanningTreeProtocol
                                         .BridgePriority
          TimeSinceTopologyChange        .TimeSinceTopologyChange
          TopChanges                     .TopologyChangeCount
          DesignatedRoot                 .DesignatedRoot
          RootCost                       .RootCost
          RootPort                       .RootPort
          MaxAge                         .MaxAge
          HelloTime                      .HelloTime
          HoldTime                       .HoldTime
          ForwardDelay                   .ForwardDelay
          BridgeMaxAge                   .BridgeMaxAge
          BridgeHelloTime                .BridgeHelloTime
          BridgeForwardDelay             .BridgeForwardDelay
          PortTable
            Port                        SpanningTreeProtocolPort
                                          .PortNumber
            Priority                      .PortPriority
            State                         .SpanningTreeState
            Enable
            PathCost                      .PortPathCost
            DesignatedRoot                .DesignatedRoot
            DesignatedCost                .DesignatedCost
            DesignatedBridge              .DesignatedBridge
            DesignatedPort                .DesignatedPort
            ForwardTransitions
        dot1dTp
          LearnedEntryDiscards          BridgeFilter.DatabaseSize
                                          .NumDynamic,NumStatic
          AgingTime                     BridgeFilter.AgingTime
          FdbTable
            Address
            Port
            Status
          PortTable
            Port
            MaxInfo
            InFrames                    BridgePort.FramesReceived
            OutFrames                     .ForwardOutbound
            InDiscards                    .DiscardInbound
        dot1dStatic
          StaticTable
            Address
            ReceivePort
            AllowedToGoTo
            Status

The following IEEE 802.1d management objects have not been included in the Bridge MIB for the indicated reasons.

      IEEE 802.1d Object              Disposition
      Bridge.BridgeName               Same as sysDescr (MIB II)
      Bridge.BridgeUpTime             Same as sysUpTime (MIB II)
      Bridge.PortAddresses            Same as ifPhysAddress (MIB II)
      BridgePort.PortName             Same as ifDescr (MIB II)
      BridgePort.PortType             Same as ifType (MIB II)
      BridgePort.RoutingType          Derivable from the implemented
                                      groups
      SpanningTreeProtocol
          .BridgeIdentifier           Combination of dot1dStpPriority
                                      and dot1dBaseBridgeAddress
          .TopologyChange             Since this is transitory, it
                                      is not considered useful.
      SpanningTreeProtocolPort
          .Uptime                     Same as ifLastChange (MIB II)
          .PortIdentifier             Combination of dot1dStpPort
                                      and dot1dStpPortPriority
          .TopologyChangeAcknowledged Since this is transitory, it
                                      is not considered useful.
          .DiscardLackOfBuffers       Redundant
      Transmission Priority           These objects are not required
                                      as per the Pics Proforma and
                                      not considered useful.
          .TransmissionPriorityName
          .OutboundUserPriority
          .OutboundAccessPriority

The dot1dBase Group

This mandatory group contains the objects which are applicable to all types of bridges.

The dot1dStp Group

This group contains the objects that denote the bridge's state with respect to the Spanning Tree Protocol. If a node does not implemented the Spanning Tree Protocol, this group will not be implemented.

The dot1dSr Group

This group contains the objects that describe the entity's state with respect to source route bridging. If source routing is not supported this group will not be implemented. This group is applicable to source route only, and SRT bridges. This group will be described in a separate document applicable only to source route bridging.

The dot1dTp Group

This group contains objects that describe the entity's state with respect to transparent bridging. If transparent bridging is not supported this group will not be implemented. This group is applicable to transparent only and SRT bridges.

The dot1dStatic Group

This group contains objects that describe the entity's state with respect to destination-address filtering. If destination-address filtering is not supported this group will not be implemented. This group is applicable to any type of bridge which performs destination-address filtering.

Relationship to Other MIBs

As described above, some IEEE 802.1d management objects have not been included in this MIB because they overlap with objects in other MIBs applicable to a bridge implementing this MIB. In particular, it is assumed that a bridge implementing this MIB will also implement (at least) the 'system' group and the 'interfaces' group defined in MIB- II [6].

Relationship to the 'system' group

In MIB-II, the 'system' group is defined as being mandatory for all systems such that each managed entity contains one instance of each

object in the 'system' group. Thus, those objects apply to the entity as a whole irrespective of whether the entity's sole functionality is bridging, or whether bridging is only a subset of the entity's functionality.

Relationship to the 'interfaces' group

In MIB-II, the 'interfaces' group is defined as being mandatory for all systems and contains information on an entity's interfaces, where each interface is thought of as being attached to a `subnetwork'. (Note that this term is not to be confused with `subnet' which refers to an addressing partitioning scheme used in the Internet suite of protocols.) The term 'segment' is used in this memo to refer to such a subnetwork, whether it be an Ethernet segment, a 'ring', a WAN link, or even an X.25 virtual circuit.

Implicit in this Bridge MIB is the notion of ports on a bridge. Each of these ports is associated with one interface of the 'interfaces' group, and in most situations, each port is associated with a different interface. However, there are situations in which multiple ports are associated with the same interface. An example of such a situation would be several ports each corresponding one-to-one with several X.25 virtual circuits but all on the same interface.

Each port is uniquely identified by a port number. A port number has no mandatory relationship to an interface number, but in the simple case a port number will have the same value as the corresponding interface's interface number. Port numbers are in the range (1..dot1dBaseNumPorts).

Some entities perform other functionality as well as bridging through the sending and receiving of data on their interfaces. In such situations, only a subset of the data sent/received on an interface is within the domain of the entity's bridging functionality. This subset is considered to be delineated according to a set of protocols, with some protocols being bridged, and other protocols not being bridged. For example, in an entity which exclusively performed bridging, all protocols would be considered as being bridged, whereas in an entity which performed IP routing on IP datagrams and only bridged other protocols, only the non-IP data would be considered as being bridged.

Thus, this Bridge MIB (and in particular, its counters) are applicable only to that subset of the data on an entity's interfaces which is sent/received for a protocol being bridged. All such data is sent/received via the ports of the bridge.

Textual Conventions

The datatypes, MacAddress, BridgeId and Timeout, are used as textual conventions in this document. These textual conventions have NO effect on either the syntax nor the semantics of any managed object. Objects defined using these conventions are always encoded by means of the rules that define their primitive type. Hence, no changes to the SMI or the SNMP are necessary to accommodate these textual conventions which are adopted merely for the convenience of readers.

Changes from RFC 1286

      (1)  Updated all text to remove references to source route
           bridging where not applicable.  SR MIB will be a separate
           document.
      (2)  Removed dot1dSrPortTable.  Retained OID definition of
           dot1dSr.
      (3)  Updated all references of "draft P802.1d/D9" to "IEEE
           802.1D-1990".
      (4)  Updated bibliography.
      (5)  Added clarification to description of dot1dPortPathCost.
      (6)  Put recommended default in description of
           dot1dStaticAllowedToGoTo.
      (7)  Put recommended default in description of
           dot1dStaticStatus.
      (8)  Put recommended default in description of
           dot1dTpAgingTime.  Specified range of (10..1000000).
      (9)  Updated all port number syntaxes, when used as index, to
           use the range (1..65535).
      (10) Updated definition of dot1dTpPortInFrames and
           dot1dTpPortOutFrames.
      (11) Added text to the traps indicating that they are
           optional.
      (12) Clarified definition of dot1dStpForwardDelay.

Definitions

      BRIDGE-MIB DEFINITIONS ::= BEGIN
      IMPORTS
                 Counter, TimeTicks
                         FROM RFC1155-SMI
                 mib-2
                         FROM RFC1213-MIB
                 OBJECT-TYPE
                         FROM RFC-1212
                 TRAP-TYPE
                         FROM RFC-1215;
      -- All representations of MAC addresses in this MIB Module
      -- use, as a textual convention (i.e. this convention does
      -- not affect their encoding), the data type:
      MacAddress ::= OCTET STRING (SIZE (6))    -- a 6 octet address
                                                -- in the
                                                -- "canonical"
                                                -- order
      -- defined by IEEE 802.1a, i.e., as if it were transmitted
      -- least significant bit first, even though 802.5 (in
      -- contrast to other n802.x protocols) requires MAC
      -- addresses to be transmitted most significant bit first.
      --
      -- 16-bit addresses, if needed, are represented by setting
      -- their upper 4 octets to all 0's, i.e., AAFF would be
      -- represented as 00000000AAFF.
      -- Similarly, all representations of Bridge-Id in this MIB
      -- Module use, as a textual convention (i.e. this
      -- convention does not affect their encoding), the data
      -- type:
      BridgeId ::= OCTET STRING (SIZE (8))   -- the
                                             -- Bridge-Identifier
                                             -- as used in the
                                             -- Spanning Tree
      -- Protocol to uniquely identify a bridge.  Its first two
      -- octets (in network byte order) contain a priority
      -- value and its last 6 octets contain the MAC address
      -- used to refer to a bridge in a unique fashion
      -- (typically, the numerically smallest MAC address
      -- of all ports on the bridge).
      -- Several objects in this MIB module represent values of
      -- timers used by the Spanning Tree Protocol.  In this
      -- MIB, these timers have values in units of hundreths of
      -- a second (i.e. 1/100 secs).
      -- These timers, when stored in a Spanning Tree Protocol's
      -- BPDU, are in units of 1/256 seconds.  Note, however,
      -- that 802.1D-1990 specifies a settable granularity of
      -- no more than 1 second for these timers.  To avoid
      -- ambiguity, a data type is defined here as a textual
      -- convention and all representation of these timers
      -- in this MIB module are defined using this data type.  An
      -- algorithm is also defined for converting between the
      -- different units, to ensure a timer's value is not
      -- distorted by multiple conversions.
      -- The data type is:
      Timeout ::= INTEGER -- a STP timer in units of 1/100 seconds
      -- To convert a Timeout value into a value in units of
      -- 1/256 seconds, the following algorithm should be used:
      --
      --      b  = floor( (n * 256) / 100)
      --
      -- where:
      --      floor   =  quotient [ignore remainder]
      --      n is the value in 1/100 second units
      --      b is the value in 1/256 second units
      --
      -- To convert the value from 1/256 second units back to
      -- 1/100 seconds, the following algorithm should be used:
      --
      --      n = ceiling( (b * 100) / 256)
      --
      -- where:
      --      ceiling =  quotient [if remainder is 0], or
      --                 quotient + 1 [if remainder is non-zero]
      --      n is the value in 1/100 second units
      --      b is the value in 1/256 second units
      --
      -- Note: it is important that the arithmetic operations are
      -- done in the order specified (i.e., multiply first, divide
      -- second).
         dot1dBridge   OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { mib-2 17 }
      -- groups in the Bridge MIB
      dot1dBase     OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { dot1dBridge 1 }
      dot1dStp      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { dot1dBridge 2 }
      dot1dSr       OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { dot1dBridge 3 }
      -- separately documented
      dot1dTp       OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { dot1dBridge 4 }
      dot1dStatic   OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { dot1dBridge 5 }
      -- the dot1dBase group
      -- Implementation of the dot1dBase group is mandatory for all
      -- bridges.
      dot1dBaseBridgeAddress OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  MacAddress
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The MAC address used by this bridge when it must
                  be referred to in a unique fashion.   It is
                  recommended that this be the numerically smallest
                  MAC address of all ports that belong to this
                  bridge.  However it is only required to be unique.
                  When concatenated with dot1dStpPriority a unique
                  BridgeIdentifier is formed which is used in the
                  Spanning Tree Protocol."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Sections 6.4.1.1.3 and 3.12.5"
          ::= { dot1dBase 1 }
      dot1dBaseNumPorts OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The number of ports controlled by this bridging
                  entity."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.4.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dBase 2 }
      dot1dBaseType OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER {
                      unknown(1),
                      transparent-only(2),
                      sourceroute-only(3),
                      srt(4)
                  }
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "Indicates what type of bridging this bridge can
                  perform.  If a bridge is actually performing a
                  certain type of bridging this will be indicated by
                  entries in the port table for the given type."
          ::= { dot1dBase 3 }
      -- The Generic Bridge Port Table
      dot1dBasePortTable OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  SEQUENCE OF Dot1dBasePortEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A table that contains generic information about
                  every port that is associated with this bridge.
                  Transparent, source-route, and srt ports are
                  included."
          ::= { dot1dBase 4 }
      dot1dBasePortEntry OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Dot1dBasePortEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A list of information for each port of the
                  bridge."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.4.2, 6.6.1"
          INDEX  { dot1dBasePort }
          ::= { dot1dBasePortTable 1 }
      Dot1dBasePortEntry ::=
          SEQUENCE {
              dot1dBasePort
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dBasePortIfIndex
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dBasePortCircuit
                  OBJECT IDENTIFIER,
              dot1dBasePortDelayExceededDiscards
                  Counter,
              dot1dBasePortMtuExceededDiscards
                  Counter
          }
      dot1dBasePort OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER (1..65535)
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The port number of the port for which this entry
                  contains bridge management information."
          ::= { dot1dBasePortEntry 1 }
      dot1dBasePortIfIndex OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The value of the instance of the ifIndex object,
                  defined in MIB-II, for the interface corresponding
                  to this port."
          ::= { dot1dBasePortEntry 2 }
      dot1dBasePortCircuit OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  OBJECT IDENTIFIER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "For a port which (potentially) has the same value
                  of dot1dBasePortIfIndex as another port on the
                  same bridge, this object contains the name of an
                  object instance unique to this port.  For example,
                  in the case where multiple ports correspond one-
                  to-one with multiple X.25 virtual circuits, this
                  value might identify an (e.g., the first) object
                  instance associated with the X.25 virtual circuit
                  corresponding to this port.
                  For a port which has a unique value of
                  dot1dBasePortIfIndex, this object can have the
                  value { 0 0 }."
          ::= { dot1dBasePortEntry 3 }
      dot1dBasePortDelayExceededDiscards OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Counter
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The number of frames discarded by this port due
                  to excessive transit delay through the bridge.  It
                  is incremented by both transparent and source
                  route bridges."
          REFERENCE
                   "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.6.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dBasePortEntry 4 }
      dot1dBasePortMtuExceededDiscards OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Counter
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The number of frames discarded by this port due
                  to an excessive size.  It is incremented by both
                  transparent and source route bridges."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.6.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dBasePortEntry 5 }
      -- the dot1dStp group
      -- Implementation of the dot1dStp group is optional.  It is
      -- implemented by those bridges that support the Spanning Tree
      -- Protocol.
      dot1dStpProtocolSpecification OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER {
                      unknown(1),
                      decLb100(2),
                      ieee8021d(3)
                  }
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "An indication of what version of the Spanning
                  Tree Protocol is being run.  The value
                  'decLb100(2)' indicates the DEC LANbridge 100
                  Spanning Tree protocol.  IEEE 802.1d
                  implementations will return 'ieee8021d(3)'.  If
                  future versions of the IEEE Spanning Tree Protocol
                  are released that are incompatible with the
                  current version a new value will be defined."
          ::= { dot1dStp 1 }
      dot1dStpPriority OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER (0..65535)
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The value of the write-able portion of the Bridge
                  ID, i.e., the first two octets of the (8 octet
                  long) Bridge ID.  The other (last) 6 octets of the
                  Bridge ID are given by the value of
                  dot1dBaseBridgeAddress."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.7"
          ::= { dot1dStp 2 }
      dot1dStpTimeSinceTopologyChange OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  TimeTicks
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The time (in hundredths of a second) since the
                  last time a topology change was detected by the
                  bridge entity."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.8.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dStp 3 }
      dot1dStpTopChanges OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Counter
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The total number of topology changes detected by
                  this bridge since the management entity was last
                  reset or initialized."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.8.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dStp 4 }
      dot1dStpDesignatedRoot OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  BridgeId
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The bridge identifier of the root of the spanning
                  tree as determined by the Spanning Tree Protocol
                  as executed by this node.  This value is used as
                  the Root Identifier parameter in all Configuration
                  Bridge PDUs originated by this node."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.1"
          ::= { dot1dStp 5 }
      dot1dStpRootCost OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The cost of the path to the root as seen from
                  this bridge."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.2"
          ::= { dot1dStp 6 }
      dot1dStpRootPort OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The port number of the port which offers the
                  lowest cost path from this bridge to the root
                  bridge."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.3"
          ::= { dot1dStp 7 }
      dot1dStpMaxAge OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Timeout
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The maximum age of Spanning Tree Protocol
                  information learned from the network on any port
                  before it is discarded, in units of hundredths of
                  a second.  This is the actual value that this
                  bridge is currently using."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.4"
          ::= { dot1dStp 8 }
      dot1dStpHelloTime OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Timeout
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The amount of time between the transmission of
                  Configuration bridge PDUs by this node on any port
                  when it is the root of the spanning tree or trying
                  to become so, in units of hundredths of a second.
                  This is the actual value that this bridge is
                  currently using."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.5"
          ::= { dot1dStp 9 }
      dot1dStpHoldTime OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "This time value determines the interval length
                  during which no more than two Configuration bridge
                  PDUs shall be transmitted by this node, in units
                  of hundredths of a second."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.14"
          ::= { dot1dStp 10 }
      dot1dStpForwardDelay OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Timeout
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "This time value, measured in units of hundredths
                  of a second, controls how fast a port changes its
                  spanning state when moving towards the Forwarding
                  state.  The value determines how long the port
                  stays in each of the Listening and Learning
                  states, which precede the Forwarding state.  This
                  value is also used, when a topology change has
                  been detected and is underway, to age all dynamic
                  entries in the Forwarding Database.  [Note that
                  this value is the one that this bridge is
                  currently using, in contrast to
                  dot1dStpBridgeForwardDelay which is the value that
                  this bridge and all others would start using
                  if/when this bridge were to become the root.]"
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.6"
          ::= { dot1dStp 11 }
      dot1dStpBridgeMaxAge OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Timeout (600..4000)
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The value that all bridges use for MaxAge when
                  this bridge is acting as the root.  Note that
                  802.1D-1990 specifies that the range for this
                  parameter is related to the value of
                  dot1dStpBridgeHelloTime. The granularity of this
                  timer is specified by 802.1D-1990 to be 1 second.
                  An agent may return a badValue error if a set is
                  attempted to a value which is not a whole number
                  of seconds."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.8"
          ::= { dot1dStp 12 }
      dot1dStpBridgeHelloTime OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Timeout (100..1000)
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The value that all bridges use for HelloTime when
                  this bridge is acting as the root.  The
                  granularity of this timer is specified by 802.1D-
                  1990 to be 1 second.  An agent may return a
                  badValue error if a set is attempted to a value
                  which is not a whole number of seconds."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.9"
          ::= { dot1dStp 13 }
      dot1dStpBridgeForwardDelay OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Timeout (400..3000)
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The value that all bridges use for ForwardDelay
                  when this bridge is acting as the root.  Note that
                  802.1D-1990 specifies that the range for this
                  parameter is related to the value of
                  dot1dStpBridgeMaxAge.  The granularity of this
                  timer is specified by 802.1D-1990 to be 1 second.
                  An agent may return a badValue error if a set is
                  attempted to a value which is not a whole number
                  of seconds."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.3.10"
          ::= { dot1dStp 14 }
      -- The Spanning Tree Port Table
      dot1dStpPortTable OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  SEQUENCE OF Dot1dStpPortEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A table that contains port-specific information
                  for the Spanning Tree Protocol."
          ::= { dot1dStp 15 }
      dot1dStpPortEntry OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Dot1dStpPortEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A list of information maintained by every port
                  about the Spanning Tree Protocol state for that
                  port."
          INDEX   { dot1dStpPort }
          ::= { dot1dStpPortTable 1 }
      Dot1dStpPortEntry ::=
          SEQUENCE {
              dot1dStpPort
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dStpPortPriority
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dStpPortState
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dStpPortEnable
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dStpPortPathCost
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dStpPortDesignatedRoot
                  BridgeId,
              dot1dStpPortDesignatedCost
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dStpPortDesignatedBridge
                  BridgeId,
              dot1dStpPortDesignatedPort
                  OCTET STRING,
              dot1dStpPortForwardTransitions
                  Counter
          }
      dot1dStpPort OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER (1..65535)
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The port number of the port for which this entry
                  contains Spanning Tree Protocol management
                  information."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.8.2.1.2"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 1 }
      dot1dStpPortPriority OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER (0..255)
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The value of the priority field which is
                  contained in the first (in network byte order)
                  octet of the (2 octet long) Port ID.  The other
                  octet of the Port ID is given by the value of
                  dot1dStpPort."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.5.1"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 2 }
      dot1dStpPortState OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER {
                      disabled(1),
                      blocking(2),
                      listening(3),
                      learning(4),
                      forwarding(5),
                      broken(6)
                  }
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The port's current state as defined by
                  application of the Spanning Tree Protocol.  This
                  state controls what action a port takes on
                  reception of a frame.  If the bridge has detected
                  a port that is malfunctioning it will place that
                  port into the broken(6) state.  For ports which
                  are disabled (see dot1dStpPortEnable), this object
                  will have a value of disabled(1)."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.5.2"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 3 }
      dot1dStpPortEnable OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER {
                      enabled(1),
                      disabled(2)
                  }
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The enabled/disabled status of the port."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.5.2"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 4 }
      dot1dStpPortPathCost OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER (1..65535)
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The contribution of this port to the path cost of
                  paths towards the spanning tree root which include
                  this port.  802.1D-1990 recommends that the
                  default value of this parameter be in inverse
                  proportion to the speed of the attached LAN."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.5.3"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 5 }
      dot1dStpPortDesignatedRoot OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  BridgeId
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The unique Bridge Identifier of the Bridge
                  recorded as the Root in the Configuration BPDUs
                  transmitted by the Designated Bridge for the
                  segment to which the port is attached."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.5.4"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 6 }
      dot1dStpPortDesignatedCost OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The path cost of the Designated Port of the
                  segment connected to this port.  This value is
                  compared to the Root Path Cost field in received
                  bridge PDUs."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.5.5"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 7 }
      dot1dStpPortDesignatedBridge OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  BridgeId
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The Bridge Identifier of the bridge which this
                  port considers to be the Designated Bridge for
                  this port's segment."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.5.6"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 8 }
      dot1dStpPortDesignatedPort OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  OCTET STRING (SIZE (2))
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The Port Identifier of the port on the Designated
                  Bridge for this port's segment."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 4.5.5.7"
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 9 }
      dot1dStpPortForwardTransitions OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Counter
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The number of times this port has transitioned
                  from the Learning state to the Forwarding state."
          ::= { dot1dStpPortEntry 10 }
      -- the dot1dTp group
      -- Implementation of the dot1dTp group is optional.  It is
      -- implemented by those bridges that support the transparent
      -- bridging mode.  A transparent or SRT bridge will implement
      -- this group.
      dot1dTpLearnedEntryDiscards OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Counter
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The total number of Forwarding Database entries,
                  which have been or would have been learnt, but
                  have been discarded due to a lack of space to
                  store them in the Forwarding Database.  If this
                  counter is increasing, it indicates that the
                  Forwarding Database is regularly becoming full (a
                  condition which has unpleasant performance effects
                  on the subnetwork).  If this counter has a
                  significant value but is not presently increasing,
                  it indicates that the problem has been occurring
                  but is not persistent."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.7.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dTp 1 }
      dot1dTpAgingTime OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX   INTEGER (10..1000000)
          ACCESS   read-write
          STATUS   mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The timeout period in seconds for aging out
                  dynamically learned forwarding information.
                  802.1D-1990 recommends a default of 300 seconds."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.7.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dTp 2 }
      --  The Forwarding Database for Transparent Bridges
      dot1dTpFdbTable OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  SEQUENCE OF Dot1dTpFdbEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A table that contains information about unicast
                  entries for which the bridge has forwarding and/or
                  filtering information.  This information is used
                  by the transparent bridging function in
                  determining how to propagate a received frame."
          ::= { dot1dTp 3 }
      dot1dTpFdbEntry OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Dot1dTpFdbEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "Information about a specific unicast MAC address
                  for which the bridge has some forwarding and/or
                  filtering information."
          INDEX   { dot1dTpFdbAddress }
          ::= { dot1dTpFdbTable 1 }
      Dot1dTpFdbEntry ::=
          SEQUENCE {
              dot1dTpFdbAddress
                  MacAddress,
              dot1dTpFdbPort
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dTpFdbStatus
                  INTEGER
          }
      dot1dTpFdbAddress OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  MacAddress
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A unicast MAC address for which the bridge has
                  forwarding and/or filtering information."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 3.9.1, 3.9.2"
          ::= { dot1dTpFdbEntry 1 }
      dot1dTpFdbPort OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "Either the value '0', or the port number of the
                  port on which a frame having a source address
                  equal to the value of the corresponding instance
                  of dot1dTpFdbAddress has been seen.  A value of
                  '0' indicates that the port number has not been
                  learned but that the bridge does have some
                  forwarding/filtering information about this
                  address (e.g. in the dot1dStaticTable).
                  Implementors are encouraged to assign the port
                  value to this object whenever it is learned even
                  for addresses for which the corresponding value of
                  dot1dTpFdbStatus is not learned(3)."
          ::= { dot1dTpFdbEntry 2 }
      dot1dTpFdbStatus OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER {
                      other(1),
                      invalid(2),
                      learned(3),
                      self(4),
                      mgmt(5)
                  }
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The status of this entry.  The meanings of the
                  values are:
                    other(1)   : none of the following.  This would
                                 include the case where some other
                                 MIB object (not the corresponding
                                 instance of dot1dTpFdbPort, nor an
                                 entry in the dot1dStaticTable) is
                                 being used to determine if and how
                                 frames addressed to the value of
                                 the corresponding instance of
                                 dot1dTpFdbAddress are being
                                 forwarded.
                    invalid(2) : this entry is not longer valid
                                 (e.g., it was learned but has since
                                 aged-out), but has not yet been
                                 flushed from the table.
                    learned(3) : the value of the corresponding
                                 instance of dot1dTpFdbPort was
                                 learned, and is being used.
                    self(4)    : the value of the corresponding
                                 instance of dot1dTpFdbAddress
                                 represents one of the bridge's
                                 addresses.  The corresponding
                                 instance of dot1dTpFdbPort
                                 indicates which of the bridge's
                                 ports has this address.
                    mgmt(5)    : the value of the corresponding
                                 instance of dot1dTpFdbAddress is
                                 also the value of an existing
                                 instance of dot1dStaticAddress."
          ::= { dot1dTpFdbEntry 3 }
      --  Port Table for Transparent Bridges
      dot1dTpPortTable OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  SEQUENCE OF Dot1dTpPortEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A table that contains information about every
                  port that is associated with this transparent
                  bridge."
          ::= { dot1dTp 4 }
      dot1dTpPortEntry OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Dot1dTpPortEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A list of information for each port of a
                  transparent bridge."
          INDEX   { dot1dTpPort }
          ::= { dot1dTpPortTable 1 }
      Dot1dTpPortEntry ::=
          SEQUENCE {
              dot1dTpPort
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dTpPortMaxInfo
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dTpPortInFrames
                  Counter,
              dot1dTpPortOutFrames
                  Counter,
              dot1dTpPortInDiscards
                  Counter
          }
      dot1dTpPort OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER (1..65535)
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The port number of the port for which this entry
                  contains Transparent bridging management
                  information."
          ::= { dot1dTpPortEntry 1 }
      -- It would be nice if we could use ifMtu as the size of the
      -- largest INFO field, but we can't because ifMtu is defined
      -- to be the size that the (inter-)network layer can use which
      -- can differ from the MAC layer (especially if several layers
      -- of encapsulation are used).
      dot1dTpPortMaxInfo OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The maximum size of the INFO (non-MAC) field that
                  this port will receive or transmit."
          ::= { dot1dTpPortEntry 2 }
      dot1dTpPortInFrames OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Counter
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The number of frames that have been received by
                  this port from its segment. Note that a frame
                  received on the interface corresponding to this
                  port is only counted by this object if and only if
                  it is for a protocol being processed by the local
                  bridging function, including bridge management
                  frames."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.6.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dTpPortEntry 3 }
      dot1dTpPortOutFrames OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Counter
          ACCESS  read-only
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The number of frames that have been transmitted
                  by this port to its segment.  Note that a frame
                  transmitted on the interface corresponding to this
                  port is only counted by this object if and only if
                  it is for a protocol being processed by the local
                  bridging function, including bridge management
                  frames."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.6.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dTpPortEntry 4 }
      dot1dTpPortInDiscards OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX   Counter
          ACCESS   read-only
          STATUS   mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "Count of valid frames received which were
                  discarded (i.e., filtered) by the Forwarding
                  Process."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.6.1.1.3"
          ::= { dot1dTpPortEntry 5 }
      -- The Static (Destination-Address Filtering) Database
      -- Implementation of this group is optional.
      dot1dStaticTable OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  SEQUENCE OF Dot1dStaticEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A table containing filtering information
                  configured into the bridge by (local or network)
                  management specifying the set of ports to which
                  frames received from specific ports and containing
                  specific destination addresses are allowed to be
                  forwarded.  The value of zero in this table as the
                  port number from which frames with a specific
                  destination address are received, is used to
                  specify all ports for which there is no specific
                  entry in this table for that particular
                  destination address.  Entries are valid for
                  unicast and for group/broadcast addresses."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.7.2"
          ::= { dot1dStatic 1 }
      dot1dStaticEntry OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  Dot1dStaticEntry
          ACCESS  not-accessible
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "Filtering information configured into the bridge
                  by (local or network) management specifying the
                  set of ports to which frames received from a
                  specific port and containing a specific
                  destination address are allowed to be forwarded."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 6.7.2"
          INDEX   { dot1dStaticAddress, dot1dStaticReceivePort }
          ::= { dot1dStaticTable 1 }
      Dot1dStaticEntry ::=
          SEQUENCE {
              dot1dStaticAddress
                  MacAddress,
              dot1dStaticReceivePort
                  INTEGER,
              dot1dStaticAllowedToGoTo
                  OCTET STRING,
              dot1dStaticStatus
                  INTEGER
          }
      dot1dStaticAddress OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  MacAddress
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The destination MAC address in a frame to which
                  this entry's filtering information applies.  This
                  object can take the value of a unicast address, a
                  group address or the broadcast address."
          REFERENCE
                  "IEEE 802.1D-1990: Section 3.9.1, 3.9.2"
          ::= { dot1dStaticEntry 1 }
      dot1dStaticReceivePort OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "Either the value '0', or the port number of the
                  port from which a frame must be received in order
                  for this entry's filtering information to apply.
                  A value of zero indicates that this entry applies
                  on all ports of the bridge for which there is no
                  other applicable entry."
          ::= { dot1dStaticEntry 2 }
      dot1dStaticAllowedToGoTo OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  OCTET STRING
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The set of ports to which frames received from a
                  specific port and destined for a specific MAC
                  address, are allowed to be forwarded.  Each octet
                  within the value of this object specifies a set of
                  eight ports, with the first octet specifying ports
                  1 through 8, the second octet specifying ports 9
                  through 16, etc.  Within each octet, the most
                  significant bit represents the lowest numbered
                  port, and the least significant bit represents the
                  highest numbered port.  Thus, each port of the
                  bridge is represented by a single bit within the
                  value of this object.  If that bit has a value of
                  '1' then that port is included in the set of
                  ports; the port is not included if its bit has a
                  value of '0'.  (Note that the setting of the bit
                  corresponding to the port from which a frame is
                  received is irrelevant.)  The default value of
                  this object is a string of ones of appropriate
                  length."
          ::= { dot1dStaticEntry 3 }
      dot1dStaticStatus OBJECT-TYPE
          SYNTAX  INTEGER {
                      other(1),
                      invalid(2),
                      permanent(3),
                      deleteOnReset(4),
                      deleteOnTimeout(5)
                  }
          ACCESS  read-write
          STATUS  mandatory
          DESCRIPTION
                  "This object indicates the status of this entry.
                  The default value is permanent(3).
                       other(1) - this entry is currently in use but
                            the conditions under which it will
                            remain so are different from each of the
                            following values.
                       invalid(2) - writing this value to the object
                            removes the corresponding entry.
                       permanent(3) - this entry is currently in use
                            and will remain so after the next reset
                            of the bridge.
                       deleteOnReset(4) - this entry is currently in
                            use and will remain so until the next
                            reset of the bridge.
                       deleteOnTimeout(5) - this entry is currently
                            in use and will remain so until it is
                            aged out."
          ::= { dot1dStaticEntry 4 }
      -- Traps for use by Bridges
      -- Traps for the Spanning Tree Protocol
      newRoot TRAP-TYPE
          ENTERPRISE  dot1dBridge
          DESCRIPTION
                  "The newRoot trap indicates that the sending agent
                  has become the new root of the Spanning Tree; the
                  trap is sent by a bridge soon after its election
                  as the new root, e.g., upon expiration of the
                  Topology Change Timer immediately subsequent to
                  its election.  Implementation of this trap is
                  optional."
          ::= 1
      topologyChange TRAP-TYPE
          ENTERPRISE  dot1dBridge
          DESCRIPTION
                  "A topologyChange trap is sent by a bridge when
                  any of its configured ports transitions from the
                  Learning state to the Forwarding state, or from
                  the Forwarding state to the Blocking state.  The
                  trap is not sent if a newRoot trap is sent for the
                  same transition.  Implementation of this trap is
                  optional."
          ::= 2
      END

Acknowledgments

This document was produced on behalf of the Bridge Sub-Working Group of the SNMP Working Group of the Internet Engineering Task Force. Over the course of its deliberations, the working group received four separate documents for consideration as the basis for its work. The first was submitted by Stan Froyd of Advanced Computer Communications; the second by Richard Fox of SynOptics; the third by Eric Decker of cisco Inc. and Keith McCloghrie of Hughes LAN Systems; and the fourth by Paul Langille and Anil Rijsinghani of Digital Equipment Corp. After considering the submissions, the working group chose to proceed with a document formed as a conjunction of the latter two submissions. This document is the result.

The authors wish to thank the members of the Bridge Working Group for their many comments and suggestions which improved this effort. In particular, Fred Baker (chairman of the working group) of ACC, Steve Sherry of Xyplex, and Frank Kastenholz of Clearpoint Research Corp. Others members of the Bridge Working Group who contributed to this effort are:

           Bill Anderson, Mitre
           Karl Auerbach, Epilogue
           Fred Baker, ACC (chair)
           Terry Bradley, Wellfleet
           Ted Brunner, Bellcore
           Jeffrey Buffum, Apollo
           Chris ChioTasso, Fibronics
           Anthony Chung, HLS
           Chuck Davin, MIT-LCS
           Andy Davis, Spider
           Eric Decker, cisco
           Nadya El-Afandi, Network Systems
           Gary Ellis,HP/Apollo
           Richard Fox, SynOptics
           Stan Froyd, ACC
           Frank Kastenholz, Clearpoint Research
           Shirnshon Kaufman,
           Jim Kinder, Fibercom
           Cheryl Krupczak,NCR
           Paul Langille, Digital
           Peter Lin,Vitalink
           Keith McCloghrie, HLS
           Donna McMaster, SynOptics
           Dave Perkins, 3Com
           Jim Reinstedler, Ungermann Bass
           Anil Rijsinghani, Digital
           Mark Schaefer, David Systems
           Steve Sherry, Xyplex
           Bob Stewart, Xyplex
           Emil Sturniolo,
           Kevin Synott, Retix
           Ian Thomas, Chipcom
           Maurice Turcott, Racal
           Fei Xu,

References

[1] Cerf, V., "IAB Recommendations for the Development of Internet

   Network Management Standards", RFC 1052, NRI, April 1988.

[2] Cerf, V., "Report of the Second Ad Hoc Network Management Review

   Group", RFC 1109, NRI, August 1989.

[3] Rose M., and K. McCloghrie, "Structure and Identification of

   Management Information for TCP/IP-based internets", STD 16, RFC
   1155, Performance Systems International, Hughes LAN Systems, May
   1990.

[4] Case, J., Fedor, M., Schoffstall, M., and J. Davin, "Simple

   Network Management Protocol", STD 15, RFC 1157, SNMP Research,
   Performance Systems International, Performance Systems
   International, MIT Laboratory for Computer Science, May 1990.

[5] McCloghrie K., and M. Rose, Editors, "Management Information Base

   for Network Management of TCP/IP-based internets", STD 17, RFC
   1213, Performance Systems International, March 1991.

[6] Information processing systems - Open Systems Interconnection -

   Specification of Abstract Syntax Notation One (ASN.1),
   International Organization for Standardization, International
   Standard 8824, December 1987.

[7] Information processing systems - Open Systems Interconnection -

   Specification of Basic Encoding Rules for Abstract Notation One
   (ASN.1), International Organization for Standardization,
   International Standard 8825, December 1987.

[8] Rose, M., and K. McCloghrie, Editors, "Concise MIB Definitions",

   STD 16, RFC 1212, Performance Systems International, Hughes LAN
   Systems, March 1991.

[9] Rose, M., Editor, "A Convention for Defining Traps for use with

   the SNMP", RFC 1215, Performance Systems International, March
   1991.
 [10] ANSI/IEEE Standard 802.1D-1990 MAC Bridges, IEEE Project 802
   Local and Metropolitan Area Networks, (March 8, 1991).
 [11] ISO DIS 10038 MAC Bridges.

Security Considerations

Security issues are not discussed in this memo.

Authors' Addresses

Eric B. Decker cisco Systems, Inc. 1525 O'Brien Dr. Menlo Park, CA 94025

Phone: (415) 326-1941 Email: [email protected]

Paul Langille Digital Equipment Corporation Digital Drive, MK02-2/K03 Merrimack, NH 03054

Phone: (603) 884-4045 EMail: [email protected]

Anil Rijsinghani Digital Equipment Corporation 550 King Street Littleton, MA 01460

Phone: (508) 486-6786 EMail: [email protected]

Keith McCloghrie Hughes LAN Systems, Inc. 1225 Charleston Road Mountain View, CA 94043

Phone: (415) 966-7934 EMail: [email protected]